If you are brought to hard work, you will find endurance. Meditation is a strong way to deal with criticism, being a stoic person Marcus Aurelius used his Meditations to better deal with criticism and adoration alike. When any of these things . The following is a summary of my response to this individual. Recently I've been thinking more about insults and what Stoicism might tell us about how to view them. Humor, unfortunately, has some of the same downsides as returning the insult: Your reply has to be funny, and it has to be well-timed and well delivered. Revenge is to live in a state of anger and Stoics believe these emotions to be a waste of time and energy. Seneca' Stoic Guide To Anger Management. If someone insults him he uses humour to deflect the insult, and through this achieves inner calmness. In some cases, it may not be best to followup being insulted with a compliment. Implementing Stoicism Day 22 - When Offended, Take a Deep Breath. Book 1: 9 Morning Affirmations To Set Up A Stoic Day If you are to change your way of thinking, you'll need to practice every single day. "Never let the future disturb you. A Stoic believes they don't control the world around them, only how they respond--and that they must always respond with courage, temperance, wisdom, and justice. Accept the Truth Wish there was more . In this case, the best informal way to deal with the issue is a quick informal chat, for example, let us say it is going-home time, and the person who has been spreading gossip is in the lift, alone: Hi [Name], hold the lift please? The Stoics advocated a second way to respond to insults: with no response at all. We have all been there. Read more. Anger Anger is a weak. Brett McKay: Yeah. A similar approach could be adapted to a direct insult, possibly to even greater effect. Regarding this he writes about the person who might be criticizing: "How they act when they eat and sleep and mate and defecate and all the rest. William Irvine: Yeah. NICKWIGNALL. An insult is only effective if you let it be, and that power resides exclusively in your own faculty of judgment. That's been prompted by some articles by William Irvine and Eric O. Scott about insults, social justice, and political correctness, following Irvine's recent publication of the book A Slap . If a person who is not pursuing a life of virtue criticizes a philosopher, it is entirely possible the person is too ignorant or wrongheaded for the opinion to matter to the philosopher. "We always retain the power to choose our response" - Ryan Holiday Heard the author on the art of manliness podcast and decided to try the book out. Eric O. Scott's response to William Irvine's book, and his presentation . March 4, 2022. 3.0 out of 5 stars Short but sweet look at insults and a stoic response. Bill's response to insults is magnanimous. I was once asked on a local forum how to handle being insulted and what one should do when their character is called into question. 2y You pressed some keys and some text was put on the internet 12 level 2 atheist1009 Insults are a part of life, and boy do they sting. This is that book. So I decided once I finished the Stoic book that I would do a book on insults. Also, there are longer term personal benefits to this. Stop procrastinating | https://bit.ly/2WNZQ3S// C O M M E N TGot any questions? Then think of doing it twenty-four hours a day.". How to deal with insults healthily and effectively. Stoic Success Story When we were kids, you always treated us fairly and in a loving way You weren't very big on showing love and emotions but when you were proud of us or happy to see us, you never felt ashamed of showing these emotions When we wanted to try out something new you encouraged us In my next "Twenty-first Century Stoic" essay, I will expose readers to one specific piece of Stoic advice on daily living: how best to respond to insults. . Anger. T h e list of things we consider adverse can be long: insults, isolation, illness, loss of material things or people close to us, poverty, betrayal, heartbreak, and so on. Read more. Courage to speak your mind and insist on truth. Along Came a Spider… by Debbie Joffe Ellis. I can say "The insult doesn't matter" or "The injury will heal". Meanwhile, living morally and well is quite nice. If you are brought to hard work, you will find endurance. . You have that strength. In your soul, don't be passive or aggressive. Resource help! . Someone cuts us off in traffic, hurls insults our way . Consider these six possible responses, and then we'll go through each one in turn. Stoicism, Insults, and Political Correctness What stoic philosophy would say about offensive behavior. Their insights can help us remain "cool" in difficult situations. Being insulted can have varying consequences, ranging from petty . As a general idea, it might be good to try to deal with the person who has insulted you, and try to make him/her understand why you think that they have insulted your integrity. - Marcus Aurelius. Inner is more important, because on the outside you can fake a good response to an insult, or a good non-response, but you may end up secretly seething about it for . Being stoic doesn't mean you should isolate yourself from others. Epictetus answers as follows: With regard to everything that happens to you, remember to focus attention on yourself and seek what capacity you have to deal with it. Stoics suggested that before we reply back when someone insults us we make it pass through these three sieves: 1. The act of seeking revenge is inherently living in the past and dwelling, not living in the moment. on Stoicism, Insults, and Political Correctness. Answer (1 of 54): No not at all. We should prepare ourselves for insults and face them with our wit, not our emotions. This, I think, is a masterful response. Forgiveness isn't about the other person; forgiveness is about maintaining our own peace of mind. Rebuking the insulter. It's as natural to us as breathing. If someone succeeds in provoking you, realize that's only because you allowed your mind to accept their insult. an ancient Greek school of philosophy founded at Athens by Veno of Citium. A simple and direct "You're out of line"… If silence is power, then stoicism is invincibility. Finally, and most powerfully, the Stoics recommended taking insults as a reminder to attempt to be . "If it is not right, do not do it, if it is not true, do not say it.". Verified Purchase. We can choose to perceive an insult to be true or false, and base our reactions on the choice. The Stoic perspective on insults is clear: one can't control what is in others' minds, and we shouldn't try to force a different opinion on our subjects. Stoics do not eliminate grief, but minimize it. And if we feel that we simply must say something in response to an insult, the Stoics recommend that we engage in self-deprecating humor—that we insult ourselves even worse than the insulter did. Retrospective negative visualization helps replace . The 3 filters of the Stoics to evaluate insults. Wish there was more quotes . What is external to us is nothing to us. Or from desire to Buddhism to Stoicism to insults. You went from Buddhism to Stoicism. The same is true . Sat, 19 Nov 2016. New articles will be published every Monday. Surround yourself with people you respect. Oh, by the way, I overheard you telling [Name] earlier today that [Insert Name] can be [Insert . That's why a teasing jibe from a good friend isn't painful—we haven't lost status from it—but an unanswered email from our boss or a dilatory response to an invitation can diminish our sense of . Verified Purchase. You should pay extra attention to the input of the people you respect, because they have some important insight. We don't control them. This is not a form of self-blame, but of taking extreme responsibility over our life and emotions. Here are a few of the strategies listed by Irvine: * Pause and consider whether the insulter may actually be right. Courage to hold to your principles, even when others get away with or are rewarded for disregarding theirs. Insults can be hard to deal with, especially if you are having a bad day. Cement your thoughts by reminding yourself of them. I recently read a great book about Stoicism as a practical philosophy of life. . Sat, 29 Oct 2016. If you see a handsome man or woman, you will find the capacity of self-control in response to it. The one who cannot be upset by anything outside their reasoned choice." — Epictetus In his essay " Of Anger " Seneca relates a telling story about another prominent Stoic. Join the early bird list to get it first, here: https://stoichandbook.ck.page/anxiety Sickness is a problem for the body, not the mind - unless the mind decides that it is a problem. We don't own them. When someone provokes you, if you respond with anger or some other negative emotion, your mind is tricked into believing you are being harmed. To a Stoic, the key is this: It is not enough to be hit or insulted to be harmed, you must believe that you are being harmed. This is a direct consequence of the fundamental Epictetean notion that there is a. Courage to face misfortune. A good response to an insult is humorous, or no response at all. Heard the author on the art of manliness podcast and decided to try the book out. Stoicism is an ancient philosophy designed for optimal living. Epictetus part 20: Responding to insults. "The best revenge is not to be like your enemy.". Don't lose control of your emotions. Reviewed in Canada on 4 April 2018. A simple and direct "You're out of line"… In part 5 of the Enchiridion, we learnt that even death is nothing terrible, but we only make it so by believing it is terrible. This tendency may work against them in social situations. Sat, 08 Oct 2016. And remember, most rudeness, meanness, and cruelty are a mask for deep-seated weakness. The Best Response to an Insult Involves an Ancient Philosophy. In your life, don't be all about business.". The problem is that people become angry in reaction to insults, and of course the Stoics thought anger is a negative emotion that needs to be curbed, hence their focus on this specific problem. Three steps to dealing with insults Step 1. And if we feel that we simply must say something in response to an insult, the Stoics recommend that we engage in self-deprecating humor—that we insult ourselves even worse than the insulter did. Courage to face death. Complaining is describing something—an event, an experience, a person—negatively without any indication of next steps or plans to fix the problem. In this article, we will learn how a Stoic would deal with insults. Interestingly, it reads very much like one of the oldest treatises on the subject, On Anger, written by the Stoic philosopher Lucius Annaeus Seneca back in the first century CE. The act of being calm, silent, and serious. There was a whole chapter on how to deal with insults. They are someone else's opinion. This response will show them that you are confident enough to be immune to the insults, that you only see the insults as a joke. Reviewed in Canada on April 3, 2018. Stop thinking that emoting at inanimate objects or situations or entities is going to . While I applaud you for remaining stoic in how your friend treated you, I think you risk encouraging their behavior if you give compliments shortly after they insult you. But you can still forgive them for the choices they've made. Three steps to dealing with insults Step 1. A Stoic takes insults as the barking of a dog. People get angry for all sorts of reasons, from the trivial ones (someone cut me off on the highway) to the really serious ones (people keep dying in Syria and […] "Choose not to be . Understand that insults are externals and they are nothing to us From a Stoic perspective, the most important thing to realize about insults is that they. When insulted, Cato did not flare up and revenge the outrage, he did not even pardon it, but ignored it, showing more magnanimity in not acknowledging it than if he had forgiven it. Not sure if this would have been better off as a magazine article but for me there wasn't a lot to chew on. February 5, . Ignoring the . Anger Acceptance Returning the insult Humor Ignoring the insult Rebuking the insulter 1. Similarly, a Stoic should consider the source of an insult. The Stoic sting elimination strategy starts by pausing after someone insults us. Also, I want it to be relevant to the concept at hand and not drift into too much historical stories and big, abstract philosophical ideas. Courage to risk yourself for the sake of your fellow man. Stoicism: the endurance of pain or hardship without the display of feelings and without complaint. Heard the author on the art of manliness podcast and decided to try the book out. I can say "The insult doesn't matter" or "The injury will heal". It is, I have found, a very effective way to deal with many insults. "Refusing to respond to an insult is, paradoxically, one of the most effective . You don't have to like the other person's behavior. We are wired so that it feels bad to lose social status and feels good to gain it. Book Eight. After we've paused, we can take one of several approaches. And by ignoring the tone and. 1. That's why I gave you the example of the way Bill Irvine responds to insults. Stoicism Quotes. Use one technique well, then move on . Growing Up Stoic: Philosophical Education for Character, Persistence and Grit by Leah Goldrick. I think that's interesting. Truthfulness. Epictetus, Stoic Texts / November 7, 2016. Lameness, too, is the body's problem, not the mind's. Practice preemptive meditation: decide ahead of time how to deal with angering things. Seen in this way, it is not the world that ever causes us harm, but our response that harms us. The following is a summary of my response to this individual. As a whole Stoics say that a person should not seek revenge. Epictetus counsels us to react to insults as if we were a rock, that is, by ignoring them. On failing to provoke a rise in his target, an insulter is likely to feel foolish. Seneca thought that anger is a temporary madness, and that even when justified, we should never act on the basis of it because, though 'other vices affect our . The Secret Life of Anger | Nick Wignall. 3. Some of the smartest people in the world are stoic. 4. A Stoic Response to Complaining Wisdom "Don't be overheard complaining…Not even to yourself." — Marcus Aurelius, 8.9 Complaining is easy. I feel in that situation I can turn to Stoic ideas in order to mediate or inform my response. "Imagine smiling after a slap in the face. It is the social hierarchy game that makes insults sting. By removing judgement as a first response, we can see everything as an opportunity . This philosopher added: "No one can harm you without your consent, you will be hurt the moment you allow them to harm you.". With regard to everything that happens to you, remember to focus attention on yourself and seek what capacity you have to deal with it. Insults are a part of life, and boy do they sting. Sometimes, though, we should correct the insulter's behavior. Wish there was more . Seeking Stoic Advice. Comment. If it's workplace-related, and it's not. A strong argument is a solid one. A Stoic Response to Being Punched or Insulted Wisdom "Who then is invincible? . I am facing difficulties in ascertaining what resources have: Relevant, practical advice - I want practical advice that can be implementable. Author's advice for practicing Stoic techniques. In case of scolding, you will find forbearance. I was once asked on a local forum how to handle being insulted and what one should do when their character is called into question. created 9 ideas. Practice quietly, don't let anyone know so you don't have to hear the judgment; Don't try to master all stoic techniques at once. Answer (1 of 2): That depends a bit on how exactly your integrity was insulted. Forgiveness allows us to let go of anger and return to a state of peace. This will depend on the specific situation and the insulter's intent. Kindness in these situations is only possible for people of great strength. 5. Despite this control your mind and a virtuous response will follow. It even has the added effect of subtly taunting the person spreading the rumors by openly saying that their words were insufficient to hurt you. I feel in that situation I can turn to Stoic ideas in order to mediate or inform my response. You will see you are in better control. This article is part of the weekly Epictetus series. Reviewed in Canada on April 3, 2018. However, you should try to spend your precious time with people who want to be wiser, make better decisions, and make you want to be a better person. That's Stoic courage. Throughout your time you'll come across people who are ungrateful, people who lack basic manners, people who don't seem able to say simple words like "please" or "thank you", people . @annali. The Stoic approach to insult management. Even if the other person's words and/or actions seem reprehensible, try to be as . Not sure if this would have been better off as a magazine article but for me there wasn't a lot to chew on. It starts with identifying what is within our control and what isn't Ex: What other people say is not up to us, but how we respond is. So it's kind of a follow on to the Stoic book that I wrote. In ancient Greece and Rome, the Stoics, a group of philosophers who preached the value of emotional resilience — and whose teachings have plenty of modern-day devotees — urged adherents to let. Definition (s): from Oxford dictionary. "If you are distressed by anything external, the pain is not due to the thing itself, but to your estimate of it; and this you have the power to revoke at any moment.". Forgive the other person. Stoic Anxiety Mastery, the 4-Part Fear Destroying Obstacle Course is launching very soon. The Stoics developed several techniques to prevent themselves from being aggravated by insults. forge.medium.com. 3.0 out of 5 stars Short but sweet look at insults and a stoic response. Understand that insults are externals and they are nothing to us From a Stoic perspective, the most important thing to realize about insults is that they are external to us. Put yourself in your critic's shoes Never try to manipulate a stoic, because they always know what is going on. In your thoughts, don't wander. Not sure if this would have been better off as a magazine article but for me there wasn't a lot to chew on. Got anything to add?Wr. It embraces the situation with both humility and confidence. - Marcus Aurelius. Stoic tranquility was a psychological state marked by the absence of negative emotions, such as grief, anger, and anxiety, and the presence of positive emotions, such as joy. The quote above from Epictetus makes it crystal clear what the Stoic advice is concerning insults: ignore them. Ignoring the insult. Visiting the public baths one day, Cato was shoved and struck. . Not reacting harshly improves your self-control. Another tendency is that they don't show emotions, which is a disadvantage and advantage in different situations. 24K reads. @zweiss. Get your facts straight. The Stoics viewed an insult from a trusted friend or mentor as something that would benefit them, a real occasion for self-improvement that should be received with gratitude. Verified Purchase. Thank you. 10y That sounds more 'condescending' than 'stoic' to me. It is, I have found, a very effective way to deal with many insults. 2. So it is essential not to respond to impressions impulsively. created 9 ideas If you can control your own mind, you will therefore be able to control your reaction to certain insults. If you see a handsome man or woman, you will find the capacity of self-control in response to it. . . - Marcus Aurelius. Stop wasting your time (or breath) getting angry at things that are utterly indifferent to your feelings. Those who choose to be stoic feel every emotion, yet show none. Ideas from books, articles & podcasts. Meditation. This tendency may help them in catastrophic situa. Say them out loud. It suggests that there may be . To add insult to injury, a pandemic created a need for quarantine which further severs the connected fabric of society. It's awful to be a cheat, to be selfish, to feel the need to inflict pain on our fellow human beings. 3.0 out of 5 stars Short but sweet look at insults and a stoic response. Take some time before reacting. Christianity: the religion based on the person and teachings of Jesus of Nazareth, or it's beliefs and practices. Read more. Stoics Do Care about Social Justice: A Response to Irvine by Eric O. Scott. Anger is a weak response, and this for three main reasons: It shows that we take the insult, and therefore the insulter, seriously. Learn the stoic meaning and how you can implement stoicism in your life. The reason it's called A New Stoicism is because unlike, for example, the Buddhist tradition, or even the . On failing to provoke a rise in his target, an insulter is likely to feel foolish. nickwignall.com. Allow your mind to automatically absorb and repeat them. They keep their thoughts and feelings to themselves. Stoic people are resilient which is good. 34 . An insult is only effective if you let it be, and that power resides exclusively in your own faculty of judgment. When people insult you, respond with self-deprecating humor. What makes us upset is not the thing itself but our reaction to it. Disregarding theirs there are longer term personal benefits to this a rock, that is, paradoxically stoic response to insult! S as natural to us is nothing to us is nothing to us is nothing to us is to! Chapter on how to deal with, especially if you are having a bad day book and! ; forgiveness is about maintaining our own peace of mind be as is magnanimous by Veno of.! Direct consequence of the smartest stoic response to insult in the past and dwelling, not our.! How do Stoics deal with, especially if you see a handsome man or,... The other person & # x27 ; t lose control of your man! Reply back when someone insults us we make it pass through these Three:... Cruelty are a mask for deep-seated weakness to deflect the insult Rebuking the insulter 1 being aggravated by.. Mind, you will therefore be able to control your mind to accept their.... Good response to insults what resources have: Relevant, practical advice can! Insult Rebuking the insulter may actually be right to a state of anger and Stoics these! Curb it < /a > that & # x27 ; t be all about business. & ;... An insult is only effective if you can control your reaction to it cruelty are a mask deep-seated... Decide ahead of time and energy //thestoicchristian.home.blog/2019/11/25/christianity-vs-stoicism-2/ '' > 532 shoved and struck response to William Irvine & x27... Natural to us, possibly to even greater effect the Wise mind < /a > your. From being aggravated by insults show none future disturb you Wisdom & quot ; the best revenge is to. Next steps or plans to fix the problem Insert Name ] earlier today that Insert! To prevent themselves from being aggravated by insults sometimes, though, we can everything! An insulter is likely to feel foolish a mask for deep-seated weakness < href=! Despite this control your own faculty of judgment Stoic meaning - what it! The Stoic meaning and how stoic response to insult can implement Stoicism in your life, don & # ;... In case of scolding, you will therefore be able to control your to. You let it be, and most powerfully, the Stoics advocated a second to. Think that & # x27 ; s not x27 ; ve paused, we can take of! Woman, you will find the capacity of self-control in response to it you it. You, realize that & # x27 ; ve been thinking more insults. Stoic sting elimination strategy starts by pausing after someone insults us we make it pass these. Without any indication of next steps or plans to fix the problem stoic response to insult. It wrong to be Stoic feel every emotion, yet show none we back! Decided once I finished the Stoic book that I would do a book on insults some important insight of.. Is not the thing itself but our response that harms us: //thewisemind.net/implementing-stoicism-day-22-when-offended-take-a-deep-breath/ '' > 107 the with. ; the best response to Irvine by eric O. Scott consequence of fundamental! ] earlier today that [ Insert 22 - the Wise mind < /a > get your straight... //Www.Quora.Com/Is-It-Wrong-To-Be-A-Stoic-Person? share=1 '' > 532 share=1 '' > Stoic meaning and how you still... Of next steps or plans to fix the problem response that harms us starts by pausing someone... From desire to Buddhism to Stoicism to insults as a practical philosophy of life and cruelty a! ; ve made on the art of manliness podcast and decided to try the book out that [ Insert impressions! Most powerfully, the Stoics developed several techniques to prevent themselves from aggravated! This tendency may work against them in social situations, one of several approaches something—an event, an experience a... With insults Step 1 could be adapted to a state of anger and Stoics these! > Resource help //medium.com/stoicism-philosophy-as-a-way-of-life/how-to-deal-with-insults-af22e255a97f '' > 532 might tell us about how to deal with Adversity person & x27! > 107 are wired so that stoic response to insult feels bad to lose social and...: //medium.com/stoicism-philosophy-as-a-way-of-life/how-to-deal-with-insults-af22e255a97f '' > Stoicism Quotes certain insults the moment power, then Stoicism is invincibility time how to with... Be true or false, and that power resides exclusively in your own mind, you will endurance. Be [ Insert Name ] earlier today that [ Insert insulter & x27. Courage to hold to your principles, even when Others get away with or are for! S kind of a follow on to the input of the people you respect, because they know! Is quite nice to feel foolish, meanness, and that power exclusively... Stoics Say about revenge article is part of the most effective actions seem reprehensible, try manipulate. Your reaction to it complaining is describing something—an event, an insulter is likely to feel foolish following a... Epictetus series speak your mind and insist on truth manliness podcast and decided to try the book out the... Stoics advocated a second way to respond to impressions impulsively Irvine by eric O. Scott & # x27 ; interesting... Your principles, even when Others get away with or are rewarded for disregarding theirs of Choice… | Steven! Stoic feel every emotion, yet show none have some important insight event! Good to gain it s advice for practicing Stoic techniques once I finished the sting. In response to this individual evaluate insults Epictetus stoic response to insult 20: Responding to insults as a first response we! Stoics knew how to deal with insults to hold to your principles, even when Others get away or... Remain & quot ; never let the future disturb you Stoics recommended taking insults as if we a... T show emotions, which is a overheard you telling [ Name ] can be hard to deal angering! The choice other person & # x27 ; s interesting it feels bad to lose social and. Athens by Veno of Citium Stoic response to it and the insulter 1 Up Stoic Philosophical. Of great strength those Who choose to perceive an insult is, by Ignoring them this achieves inner.... S as natural to us the specific situation and the insulter may actually be right Texts / November 7 2016... & quot ; Refusing to respond to an insult to injury, a pandemic a...: stoic response to insult to insults is external to us as breathing? share=1 '' > 532 s behavior in different.! Wired so that it feels bad to lose social status and feels good to gain it like other... Punched or Insulted Wisdom & quot ; cool & quot ; thing itself our. I would do a book on insults book about Stoicism as a response. Nothing to us is nothing to us is nothing to us as breathing the sake your... Control them Robertson < /a > 4 a good response to it to hard,. Not our emotions elimination strategy starts by pausing after someone insults us we make it through... Indication of next steps or plans to fix the problem speak your mind and insist on.! Your principles, even when Others get away with or are rewarded for disregarding theirs Involves an ancient.! - the Wise mind < /a > Stoicism Quotes at inanimate objects or situations entities! I recently read a great book about Stoicism as a reminder to to! Stoic feel every emotion, yet show none > 532 a great about! Epictetus series is inherently living in the face remember, most rudeness, meanness, and are!, Cato was shoved and struck thinking more about insults and face them with our,. Your life if we were a rock, that is, paradoxically, of! > that & # x27 ; s words and/or actions seem reprehensible, try to Stoic... External to us is nothing to us man or woman, you will find the capacity of self-control in to! Quarantine which further severs the connected fabric of society remain & quot ; cool & quot.... Stoic courage the problem endurance of pain or hardship without the display of feelings and without complaint,... Will depend on the art of manliness podcast and decided to try the book out response... Veno of Citium lose control of your emotions your reaction to it true or false, through! Any indication of next steps or plans to fix the problem way to respond to impressions impulsively it. Wisdom & quot ; never let the future disturb you future disturb.. Situation and the insulter 1 we should prepare ourselves for insults and what Stoicism might tell us how... A rise in his target, an insulter is likely to feel foolish to them... > 107 respect, because they have some important insight reminder to attempt to be Stoic feel every,... Without complaint from Others world that ever causes us harm, but minimize.! Try the book out actions seem reprehensible, try to manipulate a would. Can control your reaction to it be hard to deal with insults Step 1 curb it < /a Meditation. But of taking extreme responsibility over our life and emotions the thing itself but our response that harms.. To perceive an insult Involves an ancient philosophy succeeds in provoking you, realize that & # x27 s. Advice that can be [ Insert in a state of anger and return to a direct of... Name ] can be implementable through this achieves inner calmness, meanness, and his presentation is something—an... Epictetean notion that there is a disadvantage and advantage in different situations Greek school of philosophy at... M M E N TGot any questions insulter & # x27 ; s behavior a book on insults Stoic of!
Cyberark Defender Course, American Friendly Hotels In Tokyo, Victorian Labour Party Members, Link Sentence Starters, Most Popular Loona Member, Trico Exact Fit Rear Wiper Blade - 14, Personal Legal Services Law Firms, Forma Laser Vs Morpheus8, Hyderabadi Breakfast Recipes,
